COMIC A7 Review - M.D. Geist Collector's Series

Discussion in 'Entertainment' started by TriShield, Nov 15, 2003.

  1. TriShield

    TriShield International Moderator Super Moderator

    Jul 6, 2001
    Likes Received:
    M.D. Geist: Collector's Series (M.D. Geist: Director's Cut + M.D. Geist II: Death Force) ( M.D.ƒKƒCƒXƒg 1-2 )
    Nippon Columbia/Denon, 1986/1996
    U.S. Manga Corps, 1992/1996, 2002
    Directed by Koichi Ohata (M.D. Geist originally directed by Hayato Ikeda)
    Rated 16-Up for extreme violence and gore, nudity and profanity.

    In the distant future, mankind has colonized other planets in the universe. While many planets lived in peace, one planet has been ravaged by decades of war.

    Geist, an enhanced soldier, wakes up from his cryogenic sleep to engage in another war. This time, to help the army stop the planet's central computer from activating a doomsday device.

    In M.D. Geist II: Death Force, after unleashing the Death Force machines, Geist has kept himself busy by dismantling them one by one. But now he faces a formidable opponent in the form of Krauser, another enhanced soldier who has aligned himself as the only savior of mankind.

    An instant flop in Japan in 1986, M.D. Geist was picked up by U.S. Manga Corps in the early 1990s as the company's corporate logo. Because of their obsession with Geist, U.S. Manga Corps gave creator Koichi Ohata (Aim for the Top! Gunbuster, Genocyber) a fat paycheck to refine the OAV and produce a sequel. The results can be found in this DVD package.

    Story: D-
    What story? All I see is brainless, gratuitous violence.

    Animation: D+
    M.D. Geist: Director's Cut has crude, low-budget OAV animation, and the colors of the added footage do not mix with the old footage.

    M.D. Geist II has cleaner artwork, but suffers from, well, lack of animation. Roughly 80% of the OAV consists of just still shots. And you'd think U.S. Manga Corps would spare no expense on their corporate mascot...

    Soundtrack: D-
    Bad enough that you see bad animation in M.D. Geist. Worse is that you have to put up with some cheesy music to go with it, along with some crappy songs about the guy. This is, by far, the worst original Japanese soundtrack for any anime.

    Sub vs. Dub
    Quite frankly, the voice acting is laughable. And I'm talking about both English and Japanese versions.

    DVD Extras: B
    Apparently, U.S. Manga Corps still worships this title. In 2002, they released the Collector's Series version of this DVD, phasing out the mediocre Image Entertainment version. With that in mind, USMC went all-out by remastering the picture quality. (Wow - M.D. Geist II was done in 1996 and the quality's already deteriorating?)

    Also included in the two-disc set are the following features:

    - Commentary by creators Koichi Ohata/Riku Sanjo (In Japanese).
    - Alternate angles (using the graphic novel published by CPM Manga).
    - Storyboards.
    - Art gallery.
    - Geist Rider Scrapbook - A look at the customized Harley Davidson bike inspired by the anime.
    - A really, really stupid music video.

    So far, NetFlix sent me disc one only. From what I've read, disc two just has more artwork from Ohata. And I have absolutely no time to view that.

    The Bottom Line
    U.S. Manga Corps needs a new corporate mascot. I'll take the Geist Rider, though.

    On a side note, imagine if Central Park Media decided to produce a live-action M.D. Geist movie. It would probably star Dolph Lundgren as Geist.


Share This Page